Crop is crap

I despise cropping, that’s true.
In one wedding album I make, you would find 3 cropped photos maximum.

Of course, cropping is sometimes useful. For example if you want a square picture, or a round one, or star-shaped (oh my God, how would the wedding album look like?).

Or if you screwed up. Of course this is not a really presentable excuse.

Why would I hate cropping?
For starter: Just when you think you only cut a picture slightly, say 10% on each sides, you lost almost 20% of your precious image pixels. You have only 90%x90%=81% left. It’s like you paid for a 10 Megapixel camera but gets only an 8 MP one.
Worse still, cropping tells only one thing: When you shot the pictures, you didn’t know how you want your pictures to be. If you didn’t have time to compose, it still means you didn’t have enough time so you didn’t know how you wanted your pictures to be. And if cropping lets you think “I’ll just do some snap snap now and compose later with cropping”, it’s a pure sin and you might end up in the photography hell (yes, it exists).

You have to compose as you shoot, because e.g. you can’t choose a different angle by cropping. You’ve got to learn “to crop” as you shoot, and with time you will be rewarded with better pictures.

4 Responses to “Crop is crap”

  1. ira Says:

    hi…
    i interesting with u’r web…
    i want to lesson more…
    what should i do?
    i like photography…

  2. photofactorybali.com Says:

    Well, Ira, there’s a lot you could do, e.g.:
    -Learn from photography books
    -Post your pictures on the web, discuss them with other hobby photographers
    -Visit photography websites
    -Remember to just go out, take some pictures… and enjoy, of course!

  3. Mark Says:

    Windee, I agree totally with what you view about cropping and composition. I cannot wait to be in your pciture this coming Sunday… yes, that’s me! I am a fan of the automotive industry also. Can’t wait to chat to a person who share two of my main hobbies…

  4. photofactorybali.com Says:

    Hi Mark,

    It was lovely meeting you and Mary (I still can’t help but smile every time I think about your names “Mark & Mary”, and how your Chinese names have the same meaning…).

    Great to know from you that Mercedes, which is the company I worked for, has a water tunnel to test vehicle aerodynamics (which I didn’t know before…).

    We surely had a nice photo shooting, thanks a lot. It’s a good feeling to be trusted by a very good photographer like you!

    Keep in touch…

Leave a Reply